Text Only
Diary

« Western suicide watch

Main

Howard's soggy centre »



 
November 12, 2003
Appeasement corner

Typical line of questioning from the Ba'ath Broadcasting Corporation this morning when John Humphrys interviewed Foreign Secretary Jack Straw on Radio 4's Today programme. Since Iran, Humphreys asserted, presented a WMD threat far greater than Iraq had done, why weren't we adopting the same approach we had taken towards Iraq by invading Iran? Straw properly dealt with the two twisted assumptions behind this question: 1) Saddam's WMD programme was well documented and beyond doubt and 2) we had only invaded Iraq after 12 years of fruitless negotiations. It is staggering that the BBC's highest profile interviewer can not only fail to acknowledge such facts but be allowed to broadcast such prejudiced distortions. He then went on to challenge the propriety of affording President Bush a state visit, as if Britain were honouring a war criminal -- which no doubt Humphreys thinks he is.

At the same time, he was right to put Straw on the spot over the division between Britain and the US over Iran. Britain has reverted to type in wanting to cosy up to Iran and play down the seriousness of its WMD threat. As this piece in the Telegraph makes clear, Iran has lied about its WMD programme for 18 years and has covered up the progress it is making towards developing nuclear weapons. One of the core lessons of the Iraq debacle is that the west cannot again tolerate being given the runaround from endless diplomatic manipulation. The Iran threat has to be defused.

Posted by melanie at November 12, 2003

Comments

The tone set by Humphreys in this interview went well beyond that of good journalism. It was absolutely clear what Humphreys thinks of the rights and wrongs of Iraq and President Bush.
At one point I fully expected Straw to walk out.
When will the sneering and overtly anti-Bush Humphreys be taken off this increasingly wretched programme?

Posted by: Eamonn at November 12, 2003 12:19 PM

Why are politicians so desperate for media coverage that they put up with this treatment? It makes me cringe as the politician in the course of a mauling continues to address the interviewer as John etc. as if talking to a friend.

Posted by: bob at November 12, 2003 03:37 PM

I would imagine that sooner or later, probably sooner, Israel will take steps about Iran's nuclear program, much like they did with Iraq.

They'll be condemned, but it's not like they could be hated any more by the people who will complain.

Posted by: Jeremy at November 13, 2003 09:49 AM